Regulatory regime | Clearances | Safeguarding the Environment | Managing the Environment 
Studies and Findings
| Plan and Progress |  Supreme Court on Environment
 

Studies and Findings

 

CATCHMENT AREA TREATMENT

Studies

Surveys and studies have been undertaken to aid the development of a management plan for CAT in the SSP catchment which are:  

  • Report of Inter-Departmental Committee on Soil Conservation and Afforestation: (the Dewan Committee Report), 1985 presented the findings and recommendations of an inter-departmental committee set up by the Ministry of Agriculture.
  • Report on Prioritisation of Sub-watersheds in Sub-catchments of Narmada Catchment, 199. It presents the results of a three-year study conducted by AISLUSO. The catchment of Sardar Sarovar was divided into eight sub-catchments and each of these was further sub-divided yielding a total of more than one thousand sub-watersheds. These were then subject to detailed survey to establish the potential for erosion through consideration of such factors as slope, vegetative cover, soil characteristics, surface condition, physiography etc. This information was used to prioritize the sub-watersheds for CAT.
Findings

The outcome of the study by AISLUSO to prioritize sub-watersheds is presented in Table below, which includes all sub-watersheds above the SSP and below the ISP (i.e. the catchment of SSP, Omkareshwar Project and Maheshwar Project). About 28% of the total catchment area prioritized falls into the ‘very high’ and ‘high’ categories most susceptible to erosion.

Prioritisation of Sub-watersheds

Category

No. of Sub-watersheds

Area (ha)

% of Total Area

Very high

High

Medium

Low

Very Low

123

159

262

313

171

278.309

415.282

656.456

730.575

354.541

11.4

17.0

26.8

29.9

14.9

Total

1,028

2,445.163

100


COMPENSATORY AFFORESTATION & SUBMERGENCE OF FORESTS

Studies

There have been a number of studies in three States aimed at assessing the extent and significance of the loss of forestlands attributable to the SSP.  

  • Sardar Sarovar (Narmada) Project Development Plan, Volume II prepared by the Narmada Planning Group (NPG) in 1983 contained a chapter on the various environmental aspects of the SSP. Details of land use and forest cover derived from aerial photography were included.
  • Studies on Ecology and Environment by MS University of Baroda (MSU) in 1983, used satellite photography, statistical sampling techniques, and an extensive programme of field work to determine the density, species composition and productivity of forests in the submergence area of Gujarat.
  • Sardar Sarovar Project: Preparation of Environmental Work Plan by the Forests Department of Maharashtra in 1988 was a survey listing all-important flora in the submergence area of Maharashtra.
  • Eco-Environmental and Wildlife Management Studies on the Sardar Sarovar Submergence Area in Gujarat reported on work done between November 1989 and May 1992 by MSU. This provided more detailed reports on the status of the forests in the submergence area and environs of Gujarat.
  • Impact Assessment of Madhya Pradesh Land to be submerged under Sardar Sarovar Project and Adjoining Ecosystems. The study was conducted by the State Forest Research Institute (SFRI) in Jabalpur. A detailed analysis of the growing stock and species composition of forest to be submerged besides survey of some of the socio-economic parameters was conducted. This report was submitted during 1994.
  • Status of Flora and Fauna in and around Sardar Sarovar Project, Maharashtra by the University of Pune was submitted during 1997. It has used satellite imagery and GIS techniques coupled with an extensive programme of fieldwork to report on the density and species composition of forest area in Maharashtra.
Findings
  

The MSU studies demonstrated that the forests in the submergence area of Gujarat are of low density and quality. Although they could be classified as dry deciduous teak forest and must once have supported a rich fauna but pressure from human activities and soil erosion has reduced these areas to low productivity, highly degraded forest.
  

In Maharashtra the forest areas in the submergence zone are contiguous with those of Gujarat on the south side of the Narmada and are in the same poor condition. Reports by the University of Pune and field visit’s by NCA officials suggest that overexploitation, encroachment by people for agriculture and consequent erosion has reduced much of the area to a highly degraded state. The forests to be used for resettlement in Maharashtra are also heavily degraded so that of the total designated forest area to be diverted in Maharashtra, less than 50% had significant tree cover.   

Reports from Madhya Pradesh suggested that the situation is similar there. Fires, over grazing and shifting cultivation have led to degradation of the forest and caused erosion. Study by the SFRI indicated that the SSP submergence areas in Madhya Pradesh were very highly degraded and in only a small patch of 2,732 ha of very poor quality forest most of which was hacked, pollarded and damaged, was to be submerged by the SSP reservoir. Ground flora such as grasses, herbs and shrubs were altogether absent in some areas, and under-stocked, small and bushy in others. In the absence of vegetation cover and due to scarcity of water holes and the lack of fodder, the area harbours little or no wildlife of value.   

Extensive Afforestation should be taken to overcome loss of forests and provide better vegetative cover.

FLORA , FAUNA AND CARRYING CAPACITY

Studies

There have been extensive studies/surveys of the flora and fauna in all the project affected areas of the States of Gujarat, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh carried out by the identified institutions/agencies. In general, the aim of these surveys has been to establish the composition and status of the terrestrial ecological resources. This information is being used as a basis to develop mitigation measures and management strategies. Important survey work included the following:

TITLE OF THE STUDY / REPORT

YEAR OF COMPLETION

AGENCY

The Environmental Impact Study

1983

Maharaja Sayaji University, Vadodara
Preliminary Report on First Botanical Exploration and Plant Collection from Narmada Valley

1986

Botanical Survey of India

Narmada Basin Water Development Plan: Development of Fisheries

1987

Narmada Planning Agency, GOMP.

Rapid Reconnaissance Survey of Limnological Aspects Part I, II and III

1987

Bhopal, Vikram and Rani Durgavati Universities for GOMP.

Report on the Survey of the Narmada Sagar Area.

1988

Zoological Survey of India
Note on Sardar Sarovar Project - Preparation of Environmental Work Plan for Forest and Wildlife

1988

State Forest Department, GOM,.
People's Involvement in Wildlife Management

1991

VIKSAT

Narmada River Basin Development Project: Fisheries Component.

1991

GOPA, German Consultants to the World Bank,.
Sociological Survey of the Fishing Families of the Narmada River

1991

Central Inland Capture Fisheries Research Institute, Barrackpore.
Aquatic Fauna (Fish) Studies in Indira Sagar Submergence Area.

1991

Friends of Nature Society
Eco-Environmental and Wildlife Management Studies in the Sardar Sarovar Area in Gujarat

1992

Maharaja Sayaji University,Vadodara
Wildlife Management Studies in the Submergence and Catchment Area of Narmada Project: With Special Reference to Shoolpaneshwar Wildlife Sanctuary.

1992

Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd., GOG
Studies on Fish Conservation in Narmada Sagar, Sardar Sarovar and it’s Downstream

1993

Central inland Capture Fisheries Research Institute, Barrackpore.
Status of Flora and Fauna in and Around Sardar Sarovar Project, Maharashtra

1994

University of Pune
Impact Assessment of Madhya Pradesh Land to be Submerged Under Sardar Sarovar Project and Adjoining Ecosystems.

1994

State Forest Research Institute (SFRI) Jabalpur
Pre-and Post-Impoundment Limnological Studies of Narmada Basin.

1994

Bhopal, Vikram and Rani Durgavati Universities for GOMP.

Ecology and Fisheries of the Narmada Estuarine System with Special Reference to Proposed Impoundment (Sardar Sarovar Dam)

Contd.

Central Inland Capture Fisheries Research Institute, Barrackpore..
Study on Flora and Fauna of the Command Area of Sardar Sarovar (Narmada) Project Lying in Saurashtra and Kachchh Area (EIA studies).

1996

Saurashtra University, Rajkot.
Study of Flora and Fauna of the Command Area of Sardar Sarovar (Narmada) Project: Lying Between the Narmada & Sabarmati Rivers (EIA Studies).

1995

Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar.
Study on Flora and Fauna of the Command Area of SS(N) Project: Lying Between Sabarmati River and Rajasthan Border, EIA Studies.

1998

Gujarat University, Ahmedabad.
Ecological Study of Wild Ass Sanctuary and Surrounding Area Using Remote Sensing Technology for EIA.

1998

GEER Foundation, Gandhinagar.
Environmental Impact Assessment of Nal Sarovar Bird Sanctuary.

1998

GEER Foundation

Environmental Impact Assessment of Black Buck National Park located at Velavadar in the command area of SSP.

1993

Gujarat. Ecological Education & Research Foundation (GEER Foundation) Gandhinagar

Findings

Final studies/surveys of the terrestrial flora and fauna were conducted to identifying rare or endangered species for devising appropriate conservation measures. Detailed studies of flora and fauna in the submergence zone of Gujarat, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh have concluded that no valuable flora or fauna will be threatened by the SSP. 

Creation of a reservoir in the present water deficit terrestrial ecology is going to significantly modify the moisture regime. The river & reservoir bank areas, which remain dry on high lands, will be most benefited both in the upstream and downstream by the changed moisture regime as well as greater water availability round the year. The impoundment of water will provide new scope for revitalization and rebuilding of a better and more productive eco-system. The project offers a promising opportunity for recreating healthier forests. 

An opportunity for environmental improvement provided by the SSP is the creation or enhancement of areas of wildlife sanctuaries in all three States. The function of these sanctuaries will be to provide habitats for fauna following submergence and to encourage development of a diverse wildlife.

THE AQUATIC ENVIRONMENT

Studies   

In India, the overall conservation and development of fisheries is the responsibility of the Ministry of Agriculture (MOA) which directs the efforts of the State Ministries of fisheries. Amongst the benefit’s of the SSP which these agencies are keen to exploit is the potential for increased fish catches in the reservoir. A number of studies have been carried out to establish a baseline and help to predict future conditions for aquatic life behind the Sardar Sarovar dam. Many of these studies predated the planning of the SSP but have provided a useful basis for further work and have been reviewed and synthesised by the Central Inland Capture Fisheries Research Institute (CICFRI).

In addition to these early studies, studies undertaken as part of SSP planning include the following.   

Gujarat  

  • Environmental Impact Analysis, in the Sardar Sarovar (Narmada) Project Studies on Ecology and Environment by Department of Botany, MS University of Vadodara (July 1983).
  • Sardar Sarovar (Narmada) Project Development Plan Vol.II Chapter-11 - Environmental Aspects - May 1983.
  • Sardar Sarovar Project - Work Plan for Environmental Effects (Sector-Fish and Fisheries) - February 1986.
Maharashtra  
  • Note on SSP - Preparation of Environmental Work Plan for Fisheries Development in Maharashtra, 1987.
Madhya Pradesh  
  • Aquatic Fauna (Fish) Studies in Indira Sagar Submergence Area, prepared by the Friends of Nature Society in 1991 on behalf of the NVDA.
  • Narmada Basin Water Development Plan for Development of Fisheries by Narmada Planning Agency, GOMP, 1984.
  • Rapid Reconnaissance Survey of limnological Aspects Part I, II and III. 1984 undertaken by the University of Bhopal, Vikram and Rani Durgavati for GOMP.
Report on rapid Pre-impoundment Limnological Survey of Narmada river for Water Quality and Aquatic Aspects under Narmada Planning Agency - By Department of Limnology, Bhopal University - 1984-85. for the areas in Madhya Pradesh.  
Other key studies  
  • Sociological Survey of the Fishing Families of the Narmada River, by CICFRI, 1991.
  • Narmada River Basin Development Project: Fisheries Component, 1991, GOPA.
  • Studies on Fish Conservation in Narmada Sagar, Sardar Sarovar and it’s Downstream is a desk review sponsored by the NCA and undertaken by CICFRI during 1994.
Findings  
  1. The studies covered the Narmada river system and the consequences of its impoundment. It enlisted important fish fauna and categorized them under rare endangered or threatened categories. It deliberated on impact of varied land use pattern, fisheries scenario consequent to human intervention, fisheries scenario of Narmada river in space and time besides detailed work out on threatened fish fauna of Narmada river system with reference to Narmada Sagar, Sardar Sarovar and it’s downstream. The report also gave detailed description of the rehabilitation, methodologies for endangered fish fauna including artificial propagation. The reports described in detail the possible impact of impoundment on estuary at 10th, 30th, 45th year of development.
  2.  
  3. The reports stated that IUCN Red data book of 1988 does not contain any fish species from India. It also stated that Zoological Survey of India has also not published any list pertaining to threatened fishes of India. However, the study proposed eight species of fishes for consideration as vulnerable from the Narmada River. In other words, there was no threat to the gene pool of the fishes. As these fishes are wide in their geographic distribution.
  4.  
  5. Reports describe Mitigation for formation of hydro-sulphuric sludge. Management methodology and action plans were suggested. Study suggested rehabilitation programme for fishes through in-situ and ex-situ conservation.
  6.  
  7. Studies also recommended :
    • Monitoring of ecological parameters:
    • Assessment of fishery resources
    • Biological investigations and stock evaluation studies
    • Artificial breeding and rearing of Hilsa;
    • Identification of point pollution sources and monitoring of discharges.
  5. The studies covered the potential for fisheries development in:  
    • The catchment area of the Narmada River:
    • The Command Area of the SSP:
    • The estuary of the Narmada River.
NEXT>>

TOP